Morris · check your swing

X-factor: shoulder turn versus hip turn in your backswing

The X-factor is the gap between how far your chest turns and how far your pelvis turns by the top of the backswing. It is worth looking at, but a bigger gap does not make a better swing on its own.

By Morris Golf · Updated

A bunker shot sending up the sand
The X-factor is the difference between upper-torso (shoulder) rotation and pelvis (hip) rotation in the backswing. Research has linked it with ball speed in one group of golfers and found no direct link with clubhead speed in another, and its value changes with the calculation method. Before trying to enlarge it, check that your turn is comfortable and repeatable and see how it matches your strike.

Want Morris to look at your swing?

Ask Morris

What the X-factor measures and what the research says

For a right-handed golfer, the chest has usually turned further than the pelvis by the top of the backswing. The X-factor is that difference, normally expressed in degrees. X-factor stretch is the name given to the extra separation that can appear as the downswing starts, when the pelvis starts turning towards the target before the chest does. For a left-handed golfer the picture is the same, with both turns going the other way.

In a study of 100 recreational golfers using their own drivers, Myers and colleagues found moderate relationships between ball velocity and torso-pelvis separation, both at the top and at its maximum. That is an association within one laboratory group, not proof that adding separation will add speed for you.

Kwon and colleagues computed the X-factor and X-factor stretch for 18 skilled golfers with three methods: the values differed significantly, and the X-factor parameters were not directly related to maximum clubhead velocity. Brown, Selbie and Wallace, using twelve-camera 3D capture on 19 golfers, also found significant differences between methods. An X-factor number only means something next to the method that produced it.

Why chasing a bigger gap can backfire

The quickest way to inflate the number is to hold the pelvis still while forcing the chest further, which asks more of the trunk. Lifting the arms higher only makes the backswing look longer: it adds no chest turn. Neither guarantees better contact or more speed. If restricting your hips makes your back hurt, stop: pain is for a physiotherapist or doctor, not for a swing drill.

Danny Maude's backswing lesson for senior golfers is the corpus reference for this page: it deals with turning the hips and shoulders without forcing the back. Morris would test whether letting your pelvis turn makes your chest turn feel easier and your contact steadier, even if the estimated gap becomes smaller.

What Morris would check on video

From a face-on video, Morris estimates shoulder turn, hip turn and the gap between them, each with a confidence level. It works from foreshortening: as the shoulders and pelvis turn, the line across each looks shorter to a camera in front of you. That is one 2D camera, not 3D motion capture, so treat the result as an estimate, not a precise measurement.

One camera cannot see depth or the true rotation behind your body: a shoulder line that stops short of pointing at the camera and one that turns the same amount past it look equally wide. Spine tilt and side bend also shorten the line, loose clothing hides the hips, and a high, low or angled camera shifts every reading. Clubface angle and ground forces are not visible.

So Morris compares your own swings filmed from the same spot, not a published figure, and links each change to the strike, start direction and comfort you report.

Three backswings filmed face-on from the same spot

Synthetic example: invented numbers to show the arithmetic. Not a real player and not a target.

Synthetic estimates in degrees from one 2D camera; gap = shoulder turn − hip turn.
SwingShoulder turn (°)Hip turn (°)Gap (°)Strike and feel
Usual swing844242Centred, small fade
Hips held still782454Thin, lower back tight
Hips allowed to turn905040Centred, felt easy

The largest gap came with the poorest strike and a tight back, and the smallest gap came with the fullest shoulder turn. In this invented case the useful change is a freer turn, not a bigger number; the figures are not targets.

A free-hip turn rehearsal

Practice proposal by Morris, informed by the reference topic; not an instructor transcript or an attributed prescription.

  1. 1

    Film your usual turn

    Set the camera face-on, square to you and at about hip height, with your whole body in frame. Make two ordinary swings with a mid iron as your comparison.

  2. 2

    Let the pelvis turn

    Without a ball, cross your arms over your chest and turn back slowly, letting the trail hip move back and the lead knee follow. Stop while the chest turn still feels comfortable rather than forcing a few extra degrees.

  3. 3

    Hit and compare

    Make a few half to three-quarter swings with that freer turn. Film from the same spot and compare strike, start direction and comfort with your first clip.

Self-check: Keep the freer turn if contact holds or improves and your back feels fine. A larger estimated gap is not the goal by itself. Stop if anything hurts and have it checked by a physiotherapist or doctor.

Teacher reference

Danny Maude — PERFECT GOLF BACK SWING FOR SENIOR GOLFERS

Morris wrote this explanation. The link credits the teaching topic; it does not imply the instructor endorses Morris or reproduce a transcript.

Apply it to your own game

A swing video and a description of your miss help turn a general idea into a specific check.

Analyze your swing for free

Sources

Check your own swing for free

One swing, face-on or down the line, your whole body in the frame. Up to 20 seconds.

Your video is used only for this analysis and is deleted after 30 days. No name, no email, no account.

Common questions

What is a good X-factor number?
There is no single number to aim for. Studies calculate it in different ways and get different values for the same swing, and its link with speed varies between groups of golfers. Compare your own swings filmed the same way instead.
Should I keep my hips still to increase it?
Not as a default. Holding the pelvis can enlarge the gap while making the turn harder and the strike worse. Test a freer hip turn and judge it by contact, comfort and ball flight.
Will a bigger X-factor give me more distance?
Not necessarily. One study of recreational golfers found a moderate association with ball speed; another of skilled golfers found no direct relationship with clubhead speed. Contact matters too.
Is the Morris estimate the same as a 3D lab measurement?
No. Morris estimates the turns from one camera, from how the shoulder and hip lines shorten on screen, with a confidence level; a lab uses several cameras or sensors in 3D. Use the estimate to compare your own clips.
A golfer checking a phone on the course at sunset

Your swing, through Morris's eyes

Send him a video on WhatsApp and he comes back with what he sees, the drill to do and how to check it.

Morris, your AI golf caddie on WhatsApp