Morris · check your swing

Hand path in the golf swing: what to check down-the-line

Seen from behind, your hands can travel too deep behind you, too far out, or return steeper or shallower than they went back. That path is easiest to judge against the line the shaft makes at address.

By Morris Golf · Updated

A bunker shot sending up the sand
Hand path is the route your hands take in the backswing and downswing, and a down-the-line video shows it best. Draw a line along the shaft at address and compare where the hands and shaft sit at the top and early in the downswing. A path that differs from a picture is not a fault by itself: connect it with your strike, start direction and curve before changing it.

Want Morris to look at your swing?

Ask Morris

Reading the hands against the shaft plane

Put the camera behind your hands, pointing parallel to the target line. On the address frame, draw a line along the shaft and extend it: instructors call it the shaft plane. TrackMan notes that its Swing Plane measurement is similar, with one difference: shaft plane comes from a single 2D frame, while Swing Plane uses the clubhead's 3D position through the bottom of the swing. Your video line is a reference, not a measurement.

In the backswing, hands that work in behind the body early, or that move out and up away from you, change where the club arrives at the top. In the downswing, the useful question is whether the hands and shaft return above the line, steeper, or below it, shallower. For a left-handed golfer the picture is mirrored, and the camera still goes behind the hands.

TPI uses a similar check from the target-line view: a slot between the address shaft line and a second line along the club once the lead forearm passes parallel to the ground in the backswing. A club that comes down above that slot is over the top. Club path is a different number: TrackMan defines it as the clubhead's direction at impact relative to the target line, which a transition frame cannot give you.

When the path matters and when it does not

Hand path helps explain a pattern but does not decide the flight: start direction and curve depend on the face and path at impact and on where the ball meets the face. TPI links an over-the-top downswing with a pull when the face is square and a slice when it is open. Morris treats any such pairing as a hypothesis to test.

Eric Cogorno's lesson on the backswing hand path is the corpus reference: it looks at how the hands move and the route they take from the start of the swing. Its focus is how the backswing starts, not a position to copy.

The trap is forcing the hands to trace a line drawn on a screen. Pushing them deeper or further out on purpose can disconnect them from the body turn and create a new miss. Morris would test one small change and keep it only if strike and flight improve.

What Morris would check on video

From a down-the-line video, Morris estimates the hand path and the shaft angle at the key positions (setup, takeaway, top, impact and finish), each with a confidence level. It compares them with the address shaft line and with your description of the miss.

This is one 2D camera, not 3D motion capture. A camera aimed off your target line, or set too high or low, tilts the apparent plane, so film every rehearsal from the same spot. Movement towards the target runs along the camera's line of sight and is hard to read; clubface angle, rotation behind the body and ground forces are not visible.

Hand angle in a down-the-line clip, compared with address

Synthetic example: invented numbers to show the arithmetic. Not a real player and not a target.

Synthetic 2D estimates in degrees: angle between the ground and a ball-to-hands line; difference = halfway down − address. Positive: hands above the address shaft line.
SwingAddress (°)Halfway down (°)Difference (°)Reported flight
A: usual swing58668Starts left, curves right
B: slower transition58602Starts on line, slight fade
C: hands forced inside5750-7Starts right, thin

In this invented case, swing A's hands return above the address line and the ball starts left. The slower transition brought them closer and the flight improved; forcing them inside overshot and produced a new miss. These are synthetic clips, not a target angle.

Rehearse the return against the shaft line

Practice proposal by Morris, informed by the reference topic; not an instructor transcript or an attributed prescription.

  1. 1

    Set the reference

    Film down-the-line with the camera at hand height and parallel to the target line. On the address frame, draw a line along the shaft and note the miss you are working on.

  2. 2

    Rehearse slowly

    Without a ball, swing slowly to the top, pause, then start down in slow motion, letting the hands drop as the body turns rather than throwing them outwards or pulling them behind you. Repeat it several times.

  3. 3

    Test with half swings

    Hit half swings with a mid iron, film from the same spot and compare where the hands return against the line, along with strike and start direction, with your usual swing.

Self-check: It is working if the hands return closer to where they went back and start line and strike improve together. Hands on the line with a worse shot mean rethinking the hypothesis.

Teacher reference

Eric Cogorno Golf — GOLF: How To Make The Perfect Backswing - Hand Path (The Starting Point To Hitting A Draw)

Morris wrote this explanation. The link credits the teaching topic; it does not imply the instructor endorses Morris or reproduce a transcript.

Apply it to your own game

A swing video and a description of your miss help turn a general idea into a specific check.

Analyze your swing for free

Sources

Check your own swing for free

One swing, face-on or down the line, your whole body in the frame. Up to 20 seconds.

Your video is used only for this analysis and is deleted after 30 days. No name, no email, no account.

Common questions

Should my hands be on the shaft plane line at the top?
Not necessarily. The line is a reference taken from one frame of a 2D video, and different swings reach the top in different places and still return well. Where the hands come back and what the ball does matter more.
How do I know if my hands get too deep in the backswing?
Compare the hands at the top with the address shaft line and with your chest turn. If the hands keep working behind you after the chest has stopped, one hypothesis is that the arms must find their way back on the way down. Check it on video with your miss rather than assuming it.
Is a steep downswing the same as over the top?
They overlap. TPI's over the top is a specific check against the shaft-plane slot; steep is a looser word. Read the clip and the ball flight together.
Can Morris measure my swing plane like a launch monitor?
No. From one camera, Morris estimates hand path and shaft angle at key positions with a confidence level, not the 3D clubhead data a launch monitor records. If you connect TrackMan on WhatsApp, Morris reads those numbers alongside the video.
A golfer checking a phone on the course at sunset

Your swing, through Morris's eyes

Send him a video on WhatsApp and he comes back with what he sees, the drill to do and how to check it.

Morris, your AI golf caddie on WhatsApp